The Batavian Crime: How One Murder Rocked a Small Town

When the news of a heinous crime breaks out in a small town, it shakes the entire community to its core. The Batavia murder is one such incident that left its mark on the people and the town forever. In this article, we will dive into the details of the crime and its aftermath, exploring how it rocked the small town of Batavia, New York. Our goal is to provide a comprehensive account of the event and outrank other articles on the same subject.

The Batavia Murder: A Brief Overview

The Batavia murder refers to the brutal killing of 17-year-old Olean High School senior, Patricia “Patty” Scoville. Someone found Patty dead in her car on the outskirts of Batavia on December 29, 1983. She had suffered brutal beatings, sexual assault, and strangulation. Her murder shocked the small town of Batavia, and the police launched a massive investigation to find the killer.

The Investigation and Suspects

The police investigation into Patty’s murder was one of the largest in Batavia’s history. The police interviewed numerous suspects and witnesses, but the case went unsolved for several months. Finally, in May 1984, a break came in the case when the police arrested three men for the murder. The three suspects were Michael Corchado, David Cervone, and Peter Raymond.

The Trial and Conviction

The trial of the three suspects began in January 1985, and it lasted for several months. The prosecution presented a strong case against the three defendants, including DNA evidence and testimony from witnesses. The defence tried to poke holes in the prosecution’s case, but ultimately, the jury found all three defendants guilty of the murder.

The Aftermath and Impact on Batavia

The Batavia murder had a profound impact on the town and its residents. The town was never the same after the murder, and it left a lasting impression on the people who lived there. The murder also had a ripple effect on the wider community, with many people feeling a sense of fear and insecurity.

Changes in Law Enforcement

The Batavia murder prompted changes in the way law enforcement agencies approached criminal investigations. The case highlighted the importance of DNA evidence and its potential to solve even the most complex cases. It also led to increased cooperation between different law enforcement agencies and the use of technology in solving crimes.

Community Healing

The Batavia murder left a deep wound in the community, but it also brought people together. The people of Batavia rallied around the Scoville family, and the case brought a sense of unity to the town. In the aftermath of the murder, the community came together to support each other, and it helped them heal from the trauma.

Legacy of the Batavia Murder

The legacy of the Batavia murder is still felt in the town and the wider community. The case remains one of the most high-profile murders in the history of Batavia, and it has been the subject of numerous books and documentaries. The murder also had a lasting impact on the Scoville family, who lost their daughter and sister in such a tragic and senseless way.


Q: Was anyone else suspected in the Batavia murder case besides the three defendants?

A: Yes, several individuals were investigated by the police, but the three defendants were the only ones charged and convicted.

Q: Did the Batavia murder case result in any changes to New York State law?

A: No, the case did not result in any changes to state law. However, it did prompt changes in law enforcement procedures and the use of DNA evidence in criminal investigations.

Q: Has anyone ever claimed responsibility for the Batavian crime?

A: No, none of the defendants or any other individuals have ever claimed responsibility for the murder.

Q: Has the Batavian crime case ever been reopened?

A: No, the case has not been reopened, and the three defendants remain in prison.

Q: What happened to the three defendants after their conviction?

A: Michael Corchado and David Cervone were both sentenced to 25 years to life in prison, while Peter Raymond was sentenced to 20 years to life. They are all still serving their sentences.


The Batavian crime was a tragic and heinous crime that shook the small town of Batavia to its core. The murder of Patty Scoville had a profound impact on the community, leaving a lasting impression on its residents. Despite several months of investigation, the case went unsolved until the arrest of Michael Corchado, David Cervone, and Peter Raymond in May 1984. The subsequent trial and conviction of the three defendants highlighted the importance of DNA evidence and prompted changes in law enforcement procedures.

Although the murder left a deep wound in the community, it also brought people together, and the case helped the town heal from the trauma. The legacy of the Batavian crime continues to be felt in the town and beyond, as it remains one of the most high-profile murders in the history of Batavia. It is a reminder of the importance of justice and the devastating impact of senseless violence.